Woodstock Film Festival  2017                                         Won
'Excellence in Acting Award'
for The Ballad of Lefty Brown

Western Heritage Awards  2001                                      Won                                             Bronze Wrangler
Television Feature Film
forThe Virginian (2000)

Hawaii International Film Festival  2017                      Won
Halekulani Lifetime Achievement Award                                   

Locarno International Film Festival  2016                    Won
Excellence Award

Denver International Film Festival   2008                    Won
John Cassavetes Award

RiverRun International Film Festival  2008                 Won
Master of Cinema

Online Film & Television Association  1997                 Nomination
OFTA Film Award Best Sci-Fi/Fantasy/Horror Actor
Independence Day (1996)

CineVegas International Film Festival  2008              Won                                   
Special Jury Prize Your Name Here  (2008)
For his performance.

International Film Festival of Catalonia,Spain 2008    Won
Best Motion Picture  Surveillance

CinemaCon, USA  2016                                                             Won
CinemaCon Award Ensemble of the Universe
Independence Day: Resurgence (2016)


Drama Desk Award  2002                                   Nomination
Outstanding Actor
Martin -  The Goat  or Who is Sylvia?

Outer Critics Circle Award                                 Nomination
Outstanding Actor
Martin  -  The Goat or Who Is Sylvis?

Tony Award  -  Best New Play 2002                Won
The Goat or Who Is Sylvia?

Drama Desk Award  -  Best Play 2002           Won    
The Goat or Who Is Sylvia?

New York Drama Critics Award                         Won
Best Pllay 2002
The Goat or Who Is Sylvia?

Outer Critics Circle Award                                    Won
Best Play 2002
The Goat or Who Is Sylvia?

Drama Desk Award 2008                                       Nomination
Outstanding Actor
Peter -  Peter and Jerry

Drama Desk Award  2014                                      Nomination
Outstanding Featured Actor
Fred - The Jacksonian

Drama Desk Award  2015                                      Nomination
Outstanding Actor
Ozzie - Sticks and Bones

Lucille Lortel Awards  2015                                   Nomination
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Play
Ozzie - Sticks and Bones

Helen Hayes Award  2015                                      Nomination
Outstanding Original New Play or Musical
Healing Wars
Writer - Curated original and devised text

Helen Hayes Award  2015                                      Nomination
Outstanding Ensemble
Healing Wars

Helen Hayes Award  2007                                      Nomination
Outstanding Lead Actor
John Cleary - The Subject Was Roses


Saturn Award 2019
Best Lead Actor in an Action-Thriller
Television Series
The Sinner                                                                                 Nomination

Screen Actors Guild (SAG) 2019
Outstanding Male Actor in a Limited Series
or TV Movie
The Sinner, S2  (2018)                                                         Nomination
Saturn Award  2012                                                              Nomination
Best Supporting Actor on Television
Torchwood (2006)

Critics' Choice Awards   2018                                         Nomination
Best Actor in a Movie made for TV
or a Limited Series
The Sinner (2017)

Golden Globe Awards 2017                                            Nomination
Best Television Limited Series
or Motion Picture Made for Television
The Sinner  (2017)